UPDATE: All of our latest thinking can now be found at rewards.aon.com/insights. To read our latest articles, please click here.
Indonesia recently introduced a regulation on formulating, implementing, and communicating wage structure and scale. Its focus on pay transparency is expected to spur a number of new compensation and pay differentiation strategies for banks.
Ministry of Manpower, Indonesia has recently introduced a regulation on wage structure, and scale. The regulation (Minister Regulation No. 1/2017) – requires all firms in Indonesia to formulate, implement, and inform a wage structure and scale for all their employees by 23 October, 2017.
While the deadline for implementing this regulation is near, banks in Indonesia are seeking further clarity and guidance on how to best comply with this regulation. In this article we cover in brief what the regulation is about and, more importantly, what impact we are seeing on the ground.
Definitions & Considerations
The wage structure pertains to the hierarchy of grades in an organization. The scale pertains to the nominal pay range for each of these grades (typically in a minimum - maximum format).
As per existing labour laws, both the structure and the scale should be formulated by each firm based on the grade, position, years of experience, education, and competence of the workers. When formulating the wage structure and scale, the employment capacity of the firm, including financial capacity to hire, should also be taken into account. The lowest of wages in the wage structure and scale should be higher than the regional minimum wage applicable to the domicile of the employer. All employees in different cities should be paid more than the minimum wage of the respective city / province (UMK / UMP).
While regulations have always encouraged firms to have a formal wage structure and well defined pay ranges for each grade, firms typically exist across the spectrum – including those who have a well-defined grade structure and corresponding pay ranges, those who have a grading structure but no well-defined pay bands per grades, and those who have no formal grading structure. With this regulation, all firms will be required to formulate a clear wage structure and scale to communicate to employees.
The Communication Aspect
Where this regulation really breaks new ground is the requirement of firms to communicate the employee’s grade and the pay range applicable for that grade. An employee should only receive information pertaining to his or her own grade and scale. It is unclear how this communication will take place and how the regulator will enforce and audit this aspect.
Apart from communicating to each employee his or her grade and scale, firms are also required to disclose the entire wage structure and scale to the Ministry of Manpower during the following instances:
- Ratification, approval, or renewal of company regulation
- Registration, extension, and renewal of the collective work agreement
Company regulation and collective work agreements are two commonly used legal documents in Indonesia that define the employer-employee relationship. These must be registered with the Ministry of Manpower and must be periodically renewed and / or extended.
Any business that fails to comply with its obligations under this regulation will be penalized with administrative sanctions. The penalties will be determined based on the criteria set forth under Minister of Manpower Regulation No. 20 of 2016, and range from written warnings to restrictions on business activities.
Initial Assessment & Closing Thoughts
The biggest question for banks in Indonesia is how firms should to communicate the wage grade and range to employees. By giving employees this information in writing, there is a risk that the employee may share this information, knowingly or by accident, with those from other grades. However, communicating it verbally will be difficult to audit and prove.
There is concern that this level of disclosure may open up other conversations with employees once they see where they lie on the pay range of their grade, potentially impacting a bank’s pay differentiation strategy.
An unintended consequence of this could cause firms to start changing their pay-mix more frequently, paying out a larger percentage in bonuses and commissions so that they remain competitive on a total compensation basis. We are continuing to work with local and regional banks in Indonesia on their response to this regulation, and we should all have more clarity once everyone returns from the Hari Raya festivities!